Menu of Gelateria bar Nonna Carmela Capri in Anacapri, Metropolitan City of Naples, Italy

Menu Overview

Gelateria bar Nonna Carmela Capri, located in the heart of Anacapri’s Piazza della Vittoria, offers a rich and authentic Italian gelato experience that resonates with both locals and visitors. This charming ice cream shop stands out not only for its prime location but also for its diverse and thoughtfully curated menu, featuring traditional gelato, refreshing sorbettos, and select savory items like Saltimbocca.

Among the menu’s highlights, the gelato shines brightest. The chocolate and orange bits gelato is an exceptional blend of creamy texture and bold flavor, widely praised by customers as one of the best in Italy. Its rich cocoa base mixed with the zesty orange pieces creates an indulgent balance that feels both luxurious and comforting. Similarly, the cherry gelato bursts with genuine fruitiness and sweetness, while maintaining a smooth, creamy mouthfeel that leaves a lasting impression.

The lemon sorbettos deserve special mention, especially the intensely flavored Sorbett Lemon S. This variety captivates with its sharp, fresh citrus notes, setting it apart from other lemon versions on the menu like Erdbeer Limone and Corbett Lemon. The sorbettos provide a light, refreshing contrast to the denser gelato options, making them perfect for those seeking a palate cleanser or a cooler treat on a hot day.

One cannot overlook the freshly made waffle cones, praised for their extreme thinness and crispiness. These cones add a delightful textural element and enhance the overall tasting experience, perfectly complementing the smooth gelato. However, it is worth noting that some flavors, like tiramisu, may present a more subtle profile, with coffee hints that might feel stronger or less balanced to certain palates.

Pricing reflects the quality and location but leans toward the higher side, with single-flavor cups starting at €3 and going up to €5 for three flavors. While the range of flavors is extensive and compelling, some customers have noted that a few offerings can feel indistinct or muted compared to the explosive favorites such as pistachio or the mango-lemon combination.

Overall, Gelateria bar Nonna Carmela Capri offers an authentic and memorable gelato experience characterized by a broad flavor spectrum, superior texture, and a charming setting. Though service can be slow during busy hours and prices are premium, the quality of gelato and the dedication to craftsmanship make it a must-visit destination for gelato enthusiasts seeking a genuine taste of Capri.